Climate’s Babel

Kinga Sigmond, Chemical Engineering Undergrad ’29

Protesters at cop31

“Oh, that’s the group that throws orange on paintings.”

 

Except, they weren’t.

 

The group infamous for spraying orange paint and powder at landmarks is actually Just Stop Oil. Not the women featured in the image above. These women just happen to carry orange signs while protesting the world’s failure to implement the Gender Action Plan, a UNFCCC framework designed last year to advance gender-responsive climate policy. 

 

Out of everything I experienced in the first few days of COP—-a whirlwind of talks, presentations and protests—this interaction stuck with me the most, for two reasons.

 

First, the immediate negative association their orange signs elicited in the passersby (including myself) shocked me. Everyone at COP is here for the same reason: climate advocacy. Why is it that even people sympathetic to the cause can find protests instinctually off-putting? 

 

Movements like Just Stop Oil champion a good cause but their methods inevitably create divisions: between those who agree with both their cause and their tactics, those who agree with the cause but not the tactics, and those who reject both. The negative associations generated by a particular form of protest can easily bleed into the public sentiment toward the cause itself. This hurts the success of other protests like GAP and divides COP attendees at a time where cooperation has never been more crucial. 

 

Second, per the slogan visible everywhere around the venue, COP31 is the COP of implementation. And yet, here are people protesting precisely because implementation is still nowhere near where it needs to be. Those of you who know me know that I am an optimist. Be as that may, I can’t find myself optimistic about this COP of implementation. 

 

In the plenary session I attended, considerable effort went into removing non-binding language from the draft agreement, leaving key commitments open to interpretation. Absolute consensus means that things move slow like a boulder rolling uphill and the agreements made, become the lukewarm bog between heated and icy positions. 

 

Despite these frustrations I would like to end on a high note: the people. I’ve never seen so many cultures, religions, ethnicities and languages come together in one place and it is a wonderful Babel. I’ve learned not just about climate activism in other countries but also about folklore, fashion, and food. The fact that the world can get together and appreciate each other while fighting for a common cause leaves me hopeful.